This is a three part series
- Part 1: An Introduction to IoT
- Part 2: Testing Challenges in an IoT Framework
- Part 3: Managing the IoT Storm- Probable Solutions to the Testing Ordeals
Testing Challenges in an IoT Framework
In connect to our previous blog, we may rightly define Internet of Things (IoT) or our ‘Cobweb’ as the new gigantic ‘tech-wave’ disruptive to the existing technologies with no apparent parallels, at present, or in near future. But what’s so unique about it?
It’s not an ordinary cobweb which is superficially connected, rather each thread of the cobweb can sense the activities of each and every other thread, and can communicate with it in real time. Stating differently, IoT implies- flawless communication of devices among the internal and external environments in real time through the exchange of data and split-second information, enabling intelligent decision- making. Sounds fascinating? It certainly is exciting for the users, however, not so appealing for the testing world. Let us comprehend the reasons.
Dealing with an Avalanche of Internet-Enabled Devices
IoT framework implies further increase in the existing heap of devices, making testing on all real devices a sheer impossibility. A wide range of traffic patterns, big data, different types of interfaces, numerous OS, networks, locations, and device specific features, poses a complex matrix of possible testing scenarios, making the QA testing task highly sophisticated and challenging.
Difficulties in Ensuring Hyper-connectivity Across the Multi-Layered IoT architecture
With the multitude of sensors and actuators collecting huge chunks of data through multiple networks, the task of dynamically collating and displaying streams of data in real-time may cause storage-analysis paralysis. Therefore, Quality Assurance testing for ensuring device interoperability for perfect user interaction will require numerous tests to run for longer time span to ensure reliability, compatibility, and security, in turn, hitting the time to market the product. Besides, can security be ensured even after that?
Security and Compatibility Concerns
The inflow of constant stream of data will make it crucial to ensure data safety. Scrutinizing that data does not leak when being transmitted from one device to another, and is properly encrypted, will require comprehensive testing solutions.Moreover, resolving the compatibility issues for integrating various controller devices in the existing systems for data generation is another challenge.This will not be a straightforward task and a lot of knowledge and understanding will be required along with time considerations.
Hence, security issues and testing for backward compatibility with upgraded versions will be major areas of unrest for the testers, especially when speed to market matters, and when trade-off is not an acceptable option.
HP study reveals that 70 percent of IoT devices are vulnerable to attack, and IoT devices averaged 25 vulnerabilities per product, indicating expanding attack surface for adversaries.
Source: Android Authority
This reiterates the need for thorough end-to-end agile testing solutions. Is it easy? Let’s see.
No Substitute for Agility
The need for faster releases will pull agility to the mainstream. Though both Automation and Manual testing may be required for the IoT apps; however, testers and organizations stuck with slow traditional waterfall models will not be able to survive without updating themselves.
Speed to market will be the key, and automation and better communication will need radical changes in the current testing approaches along with the organizational set-up. What does it imply?
Challenges in Adopting DevOps
DevOps will become a norm as teams will be required to work more effortlessly and converse quickly to mitigate the higher technological risks. This will be a major bottleneck for traditional organizations who will need a complete turnaround, not just in technological terms but also in terms of dealing with the change. The need for agility and DevOps will further imply increased dependency on Open Source Frameworks that can enable faster and thorough testing across multiple platforms and devices.
Challenges of the Current Open Source Frameworks
The current Open Source Networks may not be able to cope up with the enhanced platform fragmentation, and future testing needs. The current frameworks require tester’s to do more work around test automation development, and around setting up the frameworks, which will be a mismatch to the sprawling network requirements in the rapidly growing IoT sector.
Setting up the suitable test framework for agile testing requires fast and incessant testing with an enhanced pace of development and quick release patterns. With IoT, it will get even more complex leading to longer test cycles, defeating the need for agility. Further, this can consume a huge chunk of the testing budget set aside by companies, posing a challenge, particularly for the small testing companies.
Can Testing Companies Manage their Budgets?
Accessing the next-gen automation tools to ensure faster and shortened SDLCs along with the need for elaborate testing in the IoT context could mean extensive cost to the company especially on hardware and test infrastructure.
In addition, companies shifting to Agile and DevOps approaches from the old traditional approaches will need to spend expansively. Finally, if the testers are not well trained, they shall not be able to decide the right tools or use them wisely, thus adding further cost to the company.
Companies Will Need Skilled Testers
Lack of skills can lead to a big hole in the testing budget of the testing companies. Emerging technologies like IoT will need new skill-sets, and this may require changing the current workforce or extensive training, both of which implies higher costs.
In a nutshell, with the adoption of IoT-platform, and device fragmentation will increase the testing complexities in multifold. Let’s make an attempt to highlight the major problem areas:
- Security will be a big challenge and despite the need for longer test runs, the speed to market will remain a priority, posing a tradeoff.
- Companies will be compelled to adopt Agile and DevOps and manual testers will not be able to survive without updating their skills.
- The current Open Source Frameworks will not be sufficient. With the increase in a number of internet enabled devices, platform and device fragmentation problems will increase.
- The changing landscape and increased budgetary requirements, with a need for radical change in the management mindset, will be a matter of great concern especially for mid-sized and small testing companies who may be forced to go out of business.
Let us try to comprehend if testing companies can prepare themselves before the IoT storm hits them in the face. Let us sneak into probable solutions to the testing challenges in our third and final part- Managing the IoT Storm- Probable Solutions to the Testing Ordeals.